Six ways to add up a vector, priced against what they return

At its defaults it draws six ways to add up a vector, priced against what they return. Binary64 operations per element on the horizontal axis and relative error on the vertical, for one vector of 2,048 numbers with a summation condition number of 1.05·10⁶. Filled markers are the policies whose answer does not depend on the order the terms arrive in; open markers are the ones whose answer does. The cheapest order-independent policy costs 3 operations an element — a divide, a round and an add — and is 2.29·10⁻⁷ wrong; the most accurate policy here is pre-rounded, two passes at 7. Nothing sits in the bottom left. The cost of an answer that is the same on every machine is between three and twelve times the cost of an answer that is not, and the two-pass pre-rounded policy is the one worth knowing about: seven operations, order-independent, and accurate.

policy-cost is one function in lib/figures/repro.js — one sum, several answers — what a reduction's division costs, and the two policies that remove it. Everything below came out of it during this build, at arguments taken from the essays rather than invented for this page. A figure here is the figure a reader meets in an essay, and if the generator changes, this page changes with it.

Binary64 operations per element on the horizontal axis and relative error on the vertical, for one vector of 2,048 numbers with a summation condition number of 1.05·10⁶. Filled markers are the policies whose answer does not depend on the order the terms arrive in; open markers are the ones whose answer does. The cheapest order-independent policy costs 3 operations an element — a divide, a round and an add — and is 2.29·10⁻⁷ wrong; the most accurate policy here is pre-rounded, two passes at 7. Nothing sits in the bottom left. The cost of an answer that is the same on every machine is between three and twelve times the cost of an answer that is not, and the two-pass pre-rounded policy is the one worth knowing about: seven operations, order-independent, and accurate.

Binary64 operations per element on the horizontal axis and relative error on the vertical, for one vector of 2,048 numbers with a summation condition number of 1.05·10¹⁰. Filled markers are the policies whose answer does not depend on the order the terms arrive in; open markers are the ones whose answer does. The cheapest order-independent policy costs 3 operations an element — a divide, a round and an add — and is 0.00238 wrong; the most accurate policy here is pre-rounded, two passes at 7. Nothing sits in the bottom left. The cost of an answer that is the same on every machine is between three and twelve times the cost of an answer that is not, and the two-pass pre-rounded policy is the one worth knowing about: seven operations, order-independent, and accurate.

Binary64 operations per element on the horizontal axis and relative error on the vertical, for one vector of 2,048 numbers with a summation condition number of 106. Filled markers are the policies whose answer does not depend on the order the terms arrive in; open markers are the ones whose answer does. The cheapest order-independent policy costs 3 operations an element — a divide, a round and an add — and is 1.91·10⁻¹¹ wrong; the most accurate policy here is pre-rounded, two passes at 7. Nothing sits in the bottom left. The cost of an answer that is the same on every machine is between three and twelve times the cost of an answer that is not, and the two-pass pre-rounded policy is the one worth knowing about: seven operations, order-independent, and accurate.

Binary64 operations per element on the horizontal axis and relative error on the vertical, for one vector of 2,048 numbers with a summation condition number of 1.05·10⁴. Filled markers are the policies whose answer does not depend on the order the terms arrive in; open markers are the ones whose answer does. The cheapest order-independent policy costs 3 operations an element — a divide, a round and an add — and is 2.14·10⁻⁹ wrong; the most accurate policy here is pre-rounded, two passes at 7. Nothing sits in the bottom left. The cost of an answer that is the same on every machine is between three and twelve times the cost of an answer that is not, and the two-pass pre-rounded policy is the one worth knowing about: seven operations, order-independent, and accurate.

Binary64 operations per element on the horizontal axis and relative error on the vertical, for one vector of 2,048 numbers with a summation condition number of 1.05·10⁶. Filled markers are the policies whose answer does not depend on the order the terms arrive in; open markers are the ones whose answer does. The cheapest order-independent policy costs 3 operations an element — a divide, a round and an add — and is 2.29·10⁻⁷ wrong; the most accurate policy here is pre-rounded, two passes at 7. Nothing sits in the bottom left. The cost of an answer that is the same on every machine is between three and twelve times the cost of an answer that is not, and the two-pass pre-rounded policy is the one worth knowing about: seven operations, order-independent, and accurate.

Binary64 operations per element on the horizontal axis and relative error on the vertical, for one vector of 2,048 numbers with a summation condition number of 1.05·10⁸. Filled markers are the policies whose answer does not depend on the order the terms arrive in; open markers are the ones whose answer does. The cheapest order-independent policy costs 3 operations an element — a divide, a round and an add — and is 2.29·10⁻⁵ wrong; the most accurate policy here is pre-rounded, two passes at 7. Nothing sits in the bottom left. The cost of an answer that is the same on every machine is between three and twelve times the cost of an answer that is not, and the two-pass pre-rounded policy is the one worth knowing about: seven operations, order-independent, and accurate.

Every figure above checked its own claims on the way to being drawn, and a claim that failed would have stopped the picture rather than shipped a wrong one. Those checks used to leave no trace at all: a passing one returned true and the only evidence the figure had checked anything was that nothing crashed. The list below is what they actually said, collected by running this generator with an observer installed — not a description of what it is believed to check.

7 distinct claims across 6 sets of arguments, grouped below by shape — because most of them are one sentence with a different number in it, and how many separate times that sentence was put to the test is the informative part.

The rule does not apply to it. It factorises nothing, so there is no residual it could be withholding. That is worth stating rather than leaving blank: a site that reported the rule as satisfied by every generator would be counting mostly generators the rule never reached.

Across the library: the rule bites on 217 of 397 generators — 199 print a residual and 18 are exempt with a published reason; 180 factorise nothing. Read from lib/residual-rule.js, which is the same body the gate enforces from, and the gate's last check fails the build if this page and it disagree about any generator.