Numerical Linear Algebra
where the algebra stops being the arithmetic
Series

Gram–Schmidt — the series

3 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. for each previous column i, subtract the projection of column j onto qᵢclassicalr[i][j] = qᵢ · a[j] ↑ the ORIGINAL columnv = v − r[i][j] · qᵢthe three worst |qᵢ · qⱼ|:columns 7 and 8: 1columns 6 and 8: 0.13columns 6 and 7: 0.13modifiedr[i][j] = qᵢ · v ↑ what is LEFT of itv = v − r[i][j] · qᵢthe three worst |qᵢ · qⱼ|:columns 1 and 8: 4.4·10⁻⁷columns 2 and 8: 2.7·10⁻⁷columns 3 and 8: 2.4·10⁻⁸The two R factors agree to 1.2·10⁻⁶ relative. The two Q factors do not.the 8×8 Hilbert matrixone word, eight orders

    Two Gram–Schmidts

    One argument changes. Classical Gram–Schmidt projects the original column onto each previous direction; modified projects what is left of it. In exact arithmetic the coefficients are identical. In floating point they differ by eight orders of magnitude in the thing that matters.

    part 2 · orthogonality
  2. 10²10⁴10⁶10⁸10¹⁰10¹²10¹⁴10⁻¹⁷10⁻¹⁴10⁻¹¹10⁻⁸10⁻⁵10⁻²10¹condition number κ(A)‖x̂ − x‖ / ‖x‖modified, through Qᵀbclassical, either route‖QᵀQ − I‖, modifiedHouseholdermodified, on [A b]κ²uκuforward error at κ = 10⁸Householder4·10⁻⁹modified, through Qᵀb0.13modified, on [A b]2.7·10⁻¹⁰classical840×8, three seeds, against an exact rational solveQ is not orthogonal; x is right

    The right-hand side as one more column

    Modified Gram–Schmidt's Q is 4.3·10⁻⁹ from orthogonal at κ = 10⁸, and a least-squares solve that multiplies b by it is wrong by 0.13. Hand the same routine b as an extra column instead and the answer is right to 2.7·10⁻¹⁰ — closer than Householder's 4.0·10⁻⁹. Classical Gram–Schmidt gains nothing from the same trick, to the last bit.

    part 3 · orthogonality
  3. 10¹10³10⁵10⁷10⁹10¹¹10¹³10⁻¹⁷10⁻¹⁴10⁻¹¹10⁻⁸10⁻⁵10⁻²10¹condition number κ(A)‖QᵀQ − I‖classical once, Householdermodified once, Householderclassical twice, Householderclassical twice, Cholesky QRκ²uκuat κ = 10⁸classical once, Householder0.0042modified once, Householder5.7·10⁻⁹classical twice, Householder3.1·10⁻¹⁵classical twice, Cholesky QR10⁻¹⁵64×16 in blocks of 4, three seedsHouseholder inside does not help between

    A stable block is not a stable basis

    Block Gram–Schmidt orthogonalises twice over — between blocks, and inside each one. Householder inside the blocks does not stop the classical between-block step losing orthogonality like κ², 4.2·10⁻³ at κ = 4.3·10⁷, and a second pass does not stop Cholesky QR inside the blocks breaking down at κ = 10⁸. Each level fails only on ill-conditioning placed at its own level, and one variant holds 3·10⁻¹⁵ on every placement.

    part 4 · orthogonality

All series